Shared publicly  - 
 
1
1
Trevor Ogden's profile photo
 
People will comment on what is important to them, or if they are specifically asked to do so, as in traditional  pre-publication review.  With so much pressure on time, they will not usually bother to comment on papers which they think are suspect but which do not impinge on them.  This is the fundamental problem with relying on post-publication review, but there are other which are also important.
Add a comment...