This is actually a pretty funny and rather accurate take on all this.
3 plus ones
Shared publicly•View activity
- I didn't like his comparison to how google shows relevant ads in gmail.
I don't think using a picture I took is the same thing as showing me a relevant ad.Dec 18, 2012
- Using your content for monetization is at the heart of this. I think that was his point with that.Dec 18, 2012
- I guess for some reason I don't mind the kind of monetization that is making guesses at what might be relevant to me based on what I am writing/reading vs. taking my content, repackaging it at selling it.
To be clear I understand that wasn't Instagram's 'intent' but the ToS sounded a lot like that's exactly what they were doing.
The equivalent thing for gmail ads would be somehow lifting text directly from my email and using it as copy in an advertisement.
If google tried to do that then yes, the internet would be up in arms over it.
So I'm glad Instagram wasn't trying to use pictures I took as photo's in their advertisements but I read the associated bit of the ToS like 10x and I came to the conclusion that that must be what they were trying to do.
'Poorly worded' ToS indeed.
If the internet didn't have an uproar about this, then wouldn't the big company that's first concern is to make money, just go ahead and do that kind of thing? I mean if no one was saying 'hey, we have a problem with what this says' then doesn't any big company just take the path to the most money with the least resistance?
His point about knee jerk 'quitting' services is very valid. Seems like someone is quitting something every other day on the internet.
But I'm glad that this ToS change became a big deal, and I'm glad Instagram responded to it, and I'm glad it's been clarified that they wont' be using my pictures of cats and dogs and cocktails in advertisements without my permission or without compensation :D
sorry for the tl;drDec 18, 2012
- It seem's +'s, likes and star ratings culled from user endorsments in sales campaigns are geared to sell more units per person before anyone finds out product's are lacking or don't work well. Then the M.O. is to change to a new model #Dec 18, 2012
Add a comment...