What in god's name was this octopus trying to do?
Maybe that's the wrong question. There's no question that octopi are smart -- they can puzzle their way through surprisingly complex tasks -- but they're also not a lot like humans. There's only a limited extent that we can empathize with animals -- and there's a good chance that we'll get it wrong. (c.f. http://goo.gl/D8yjd)
Octopi, though. Octopi are particularly difficult, and I don't know if "volition" is really the right model to describe what this animal is trying to do.
Most of an octopus' neurons are in its arms. The rest are in a donut-shaped brain that surrounds its digestive tract. Vision and hearing are handled centrally, but proprioception, smell, touch, and taste are mostly delegated to the nerve cords in the arms. Which means that, subjectively, an octopus is probably something like an unruly parliament of snakes ruled by a dog.Â
If you've ever gotten a chance to interact with an octopus in person, you'll find that it really doesn't have much control over the details of what its tentacles do. Run your finger over the sensory surface, and its suckers will cup your fingers and the end will curl around it. Only afterward -- when the octopus actually looks at what you're doing -- does the octopus seem to get a grip on what its tentacle is gripping.Â
This octopus is crawling out of its tank. But it probably doesn't have a great idea about where the tips of its tentacles are, and -- because it can't see what its arms are doing -- probably doesn't yet know that it's trying to make a break for freedom. 
Maybe that's the wrong question. There's no question that octopi are smart -- they can puzzle their way through surprisingly complex tasks -- but they're also not a lot like humans. There's only a limited extent that we can empathize with animals -- and there's a good chance that we'll get it wrong. (c.f. http://goo.gl/D8yjd)
Octopi, though. Octopi are particularly difficult, and I don't know if "volition" is really the right model to describe what this animal is trying to do.
Most of an octopus' neurons are in its arms. The rest are in a donut-shaped brain that surrounds its digestive tract. Vision and hearing are handled centrally, but proprioception, smell, touch, and taste are mostly delegated to the nerve cords in the arms. Which means that, subjectively, an octopus is probably something like an unruly parliament of snakes ruled by a dog.Â
If you've ever gotten a chance to interact with an octopus in person, you'll find that it really doesn't have much control over the details of what its tentacles do. Run your finger over the sensory surface, and its suckers will cup your fingers and the end will curl around it. Only afterward -- when the octopus actually looks at what you're doing -- does the octopus seem to get a grip on what its tentacle is gripping.Â
This octopus is crawling out of its tank. But it probably doesn't have a great idea about where the tips of its tentacles are, and -- because it can't see what its arms are doing -- probably doesn't yet know that it's trying to make a break for freedom. 
View 22 previous comments
Wow, your book really freaked a few kids out lol GGÂMar 8, 2015
Update: Since we can not lower the water level any lower, we've put a semi-permanent astro turf covered lid on the top of the tank. There is a big hole in the middle that we can access for feeding. We don't have or need a lid for the large tank because we normally have larger octopus in that tank. When they get to about 30 lbs, they are too heavy to climb out.Â35w
I am offended, make it all Vegan.35w
27w
+Tristan Fillmore Oh wow! So they have an octopus named "Inky" like ours that is named "Ink". Both of them escape artists.Â
We released Ink last year because we only keep them for about 3 to 9 months. We're like a holiday inn for octopuses. Free food in bed. Protection from predators. Free medical care (No it's not Obama Care, LOL!). And if they are lucky to be in our tanks around Valentine's day, we set them up with a blind date that usually works out very well for the lucky couples.Â
We've since updated our small tank enclosure with a large disc top covered with Astroturf. They don't like prickly things like toothbrushes and astroturf. So it does a good job of keeping them in. There is a large opening in the disc that lets us run a feeding stick through.Â
Currently we have a new octopus named "Luci" there now. She's like a little child when it comes to feeding time as she swims away as we try to feed her lunch. As we pull the food back out, she swims up like she's just kidding and expects to be fed. Sw we send the food back down which she grabs on too rather quickly. Then processed to hold the feed stick for about an hour and won't let go.Â
I swear, it's like feeding a terrible two year old.Â
"Nacho" our big male is in the large tank and he's a bit of a player. He's gets our guest to chase him from one side of the tank to the other. Or he just follows people. Really fun to watch him play with the guests.Â
:-)27w
I hope you choke on a fish bone...27w